Background. In the high inflation
'70s and early '80s commodity prices
soared. Keynesian supply-side economics
delivered high growth at the cost
of high inflation. Irresponsible financial
management led to negative real
interest rates as inflation rose to double-
digit levels in major economies.
Investors and holders of commodities
were rewarded by a virtuous cycle of
price rises and negative carry costs.
Commodity analysts were the toast of
Wall Street. In the '80s and '90s, tighter
financial discipline and positive real
interest rates led to a collapse in commodity
prices as investors and corporates
de-stocked into a market of excess
supply. Gold, which had traded at
USD 850/oz in early 1980, fell to about
USD 250/oz. As capacity was withdrawn
or mothballed, investment in
commodities and traded volumes fell
to a trickle as selling prices in many
sectors fell below production cost. Major
investment houses closed their gold
funds and sacked their resource analysts.
Swiss banks that had advocated
3–8% in commodities in the early '80s
as an orthodoxy, reduced this in the
late ’90s to 0% as a defence.
The opportunity.Commodity related
investments should be able to generate
annual returns of 15%+ for
many years. Since the collapse of the
Berlin Wall and the emergence of Soviet-
era acolytes like India and China,
two thirds of the world's population –
previously a nonentity in economic
terms – has come on stream as potential
private consumers of commodities
as their societies urbanize. Mothballed
capacity has been re-opened but it
takes nearly a decade to start a gold
mine from scratch and several years to
cultivate a tea or cocoa plantation. The
largest gold miner in the world grew
production four times in the '90s but its
reserve life was cut in half. Precious
metal production is flat over the past
three years despite price rises. A 20-
year collapse in commodity prices has
led to a chronic shortage of capacity
and a shortage of analysts able to identify
good investments. Never before in
human history have so many new consumers
come on stream as potential
buyers of commodities.
Ways to play the theme. Commodity
funds, gold and natural resource
funds, commodity-producing country
funds. Avoid index approaches if possible
(Jim Rogers' soft commodities fund
may be an exception) and Exchange
Traded Funds, which lack gearing and
value added. In metals, super-dominance
of majors RTZ, BHP-Billiton
etc. creates need for diversified approach
through funds.
Particular factor skills required of
selected managers. Geological / metallurgical
/ mining background and corporate
finance / discounted cash flow analysis
to be able to compare "like with
like" across countries and sectors as
common discipline. A good proprietary
database as the bear market has
created vacuum in many analysts' /
stockbrokers' research.